India stands at a critical juncture in its health narrative. While often associated with a lean physique, a concerning paradox is emerging: a significant number of Indians are being diagnosed with type 2 diabetes, even those who appear outwardly thin. This challenges the conventional understanding that diabetes is primarily a disease of obesity. For years, being slender was considered a hallmark of good health in India, yet behind this facade lies a complex interplay of genetics, lifestyle, and unique physiological factors that experts are now beginning to unravel. Understanding these hidden risks is crucial for addressing what has become a silent epidemic.
Thin Outside, Fat Inside: The TOFI Phenomenon
The term Thin Outside, Fat Inside (TOFI) has become central to explaining why many seemingly thin individuals develop metabolic disorders. Unlike visible subcutaneous fat, TOFI refers to the accumulation of visceral fat – fat that wraps around internal organs like the liver, pancreas, and intestines. This type of fat is metabolically active, secreting hormones and inflammatory substances that disrupt insulin signaling and increase insulin resistance, a precursor to type 2 diabetes.
Indians, particularly South Asians, are genetically predisposed to storing more visceral fat compared to Caucasians, even at lower Body Mass Index (BMI) levels. A person with a healthy-looking BMI of 22 in India might carry as much visceral fat as a Caucasian with a BMI of 25 or more. This makes BMI alone an unreliable indicator of metabolic health in the Indian context. Furthermore, a typical Indian diet, rich in refined carbohydrates like white rice, roti, and sugary snacks, coupled with a sedentary lifestyle, exacerbates this tendency. These dietary choices lead to rapid glucose spikes, forcing the pancreas to work harder and eventually leading to insulin resistance and pancreatic beta-cell dysfunction.
Dr. Priyanka Sharma, a leading endocrinologist based in Mumbai, explains, “Many thin Indians don’t realise they are metabolically unhealthy because their weight appears normal. The hidden danger lies in visceral adiposity and poor insulin sensitivity, which are far more prevalent in our population due to both genetic and environmental factors. It’s not just about what you see on the scale, but what’s happening inside.”
Genetic Roots and Modern Lifestyle Shifts
Beyond visceral fat, a deeper dive into genetics reveals another layer of vulnerability. South Asians have a higher genetic predisposition to insulin resistance. This “thrifty gene” hypothesis suggests that our ancestors, who faced periods of famine and scarcity, developed genes that were highly efficient at storing fat and conserving energy. While advantageous in times of famine, this genetic makeup becomes a liability in an era of abundant, calorie-dense food and reduced physical activity. Their bodies are hyper-efficient at converting carbohydrates into fat, particularly visceral fat, even with moderate intake.
The rapid urbanisation and westernisation of lifestyles in India have dramatically altered traditional diets and activity levels. While traditional Indian meals can be balanced, the modern interpretation often involves larger portions of refined grains, excessive use of cooking oils, and increased consumption of processed foods high in sugar and unhealthy fats. The transition from active, manual occupations to desk-bound jobs, coupled with reduced walking and increased reliance on vehicles, further compounds the problem. Even within families, there’s a noticeable shift: children are less physically active than previous generations, contributing to earlier onset of metabolic issues.
Moreover, factors like chronic stress, inadequate sleep, and even exposure to environmental pollutants are being studied for their potential roles in exacerbating insulin resistance and diabetes risk. These modern stressors, combined with the underlying genetic vulnerability and specific dietary patterns, create a perfect storm for the development of diabetes, irrespective of outward appearance.
The journey to understanding diabetes in India is evolving beyond simplistic notions of weight. It requires a holistic perspective that acknowledges genetic predispositions, the insidious nature of visceral fat, and the profound impact of modern lifestyle choices. For a healthy India, the focus must shift from visible thinness to genuine metabolic wellness, encouraging early screening, informed dietary changes, and consistent physical activity for everyone, regardless of their waistline.
—
